Factors To Consider When Choosing The Best Trolling Reels For Saltwater And Freshwater Fishing

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying Amazon.com purchases

Discover the when choosing the best trolling reels for saltwater and freshwater fishing. Explore top trolling reels from Shimano, Penn, Daiwa, Okuma, and Avet. Learn and techniques for trolling with reels.

Factors to Consider When Choosing the Best Trolling Reels

When it comes to choosing the best trolling reel for your fishing adventures, there are several important . These factors can greatly impact your fishing experience and determine the success of your trolling endeavors. Let’s take a closer look at some key considerations:

Gear Ratio

The gear ratio is one of the most crucial when selecting a trolling reel. It refers to the number of times the spool rotates with each complete turn of the handle. A higher means faster retrieval speed, which is essential for trolling techniques that require quick line retrieval. On the other hand, a lower provides more torque, making it ideal for targeting larger, hard-fighting fish. Finding the right that suits your fishing style and target species is essential for a successful trolling experience.

Drag System

The drag system of a trolling reel is responsible for applying pressure on the line to prevent it from breaking when a fish strikes and pulls. A smooth and reliable drag system is crucial for handling the powerful runs and sudden bursts of energy that fish exhibit during trolling. Look for trolling reels with a high-quality that offers a wide range of adjustment to accommodate different fishing conditions and target species. A well-designed drag system ensures that you can confidently battle and land fish without the fear of line breakage.

Line Capacity

The of a trolling reel refers to the amount of fishing line it can hold. It is important to choose a trolling reel with an adequate that matches your fishing needs. Consider the type of fishing you will be doing and the size of the fish you are targeting. You want to ensure that your reel can accommodate enough line to handle long runs and deep dives, especially when pursuing larger saltwater species. Having the right line capacity ensures that you can fish with confidence, knowing that you have enough line to handle any situation.

Durability and Construction

Durability and construction are crucial when selecting a trolling reel. Fishing in saltwater environments can be particularly harsh on reels, so it is important to choose a reel that is built to withstand corrosion and the test of time. Look for reels made from high-quality materials such as corrosion-resistant alloys and strong, durable frames. Pay attention to the overall construction and craftsmanship of the reel, ensuring that it is built to handle the rigors of trolling and withstand the elements.

Smoothness and Performance

Smoothness and performance are key aspects to consider when choosing a trolling reel. A smooth reel will provide you with a seamless fishing experience, allowing for effortless line retrieval and smooth drag engagement. Look for reels that feature high-quality ball bearings and precision engineering to ensure smooth operation. Additionally, consider the overall performance of the reel in terms of casting distance, accuracy, and ease of use. A well-performing trolling reel will enhance your fishing experience and increase your chances of success on the water.


Top Trolling Reels for Saltwater Fishing

Shimano Talica II

The Shimano Talica II is a top choice for saltwater trolling reels due to its exceptional performance and durability. With a gear ratio of 6.2:1, it offers a perfect balance between power and speed. The drag system is also impressive, providing a smooth and consistent pressure that can handle the toughest saltwater species.

One of the standout features of the Talica II is its . It can hold a significant amount of line, allowing you to target larger fish that may take long runs. The reel is also constructed with high-quality materials, ensuring its even in harsh saltwater conditions.

Penn International VISX

Another highly recommended saltwater trolling reel is the Penn International VISX. Known for its strength and reliability, this reel is designed to handle big game fish with ease. It features a of 5.1:1, providing plenty of torque for battling large saltwater species.

The drag system of the Penn International VISX is exceptional, offering smooth and consistent pressure throughout the fight. This reel also has a generous , allowing you to spool up with enough line for long-distance trolling.

Daiwa Saltiga

The Daiwa Saltiga is a popular choice among seasoned saltwater anglers. It boasts a gear ratio of 6.4:1, making it an ideal reel for fast and aggressive trolling. The of the Saltiga is highly regarded, providing the necessary stopping power to control powerful saltwater fish.

When it comes to , the Daiwa Saltiga doesn’t disappoint. It can hold a substantial amount of line, giving you the confidence to target trophy-sized fish. The reel’s construction is also top-notch, ensuring its longevity even in demanding saltwater environments.

Okuma Makaira

If you’re looking for a trolling reel that combines power and precision, the Okuma Makaira is worth considering. With a of 4.7:1, this reel offers excellent torque for battling large saltwater species. The drag system is also exceptional, providing smooth and reliable performance when it matters most.

The Okuma Makaira has a generous line capacity, allowing you to spool up with enough line for long trolling runs. Its construction is built to withstand the harsh conditions of , ensuring its durability and longevity.

Avet MXL

The Avet MXL is a versatile trolling reel that excels in saltwater environments. With a of 6.3:1, it offers a good balance of speed and power for trolling applications. The drag system of the MXL is highly reliable, providing consistent pressure throughout the fight.

This reel has a decent , allowing you to spool up with enough line for various trolling scenarios. The Avet MXL is also known for its durability and construction, making it a reliable choice for saltwater anglers.


Best Trolling Reels for Freshwater Fishing

Abu Garcia Ambassadeur C3

The Abu Garcia Ambassadeur C3 is a top-notch trolling reel that is widely recognized for its exceptional performance in freshwater fishing. With its smooth and reliable operation, this reel is a favorite among anglers who enjoy targeting freshwater species such as bass, trout, and walleye. The Ambassadeur C3 boasts a durable construction, featuring a corrosion-resistant frame and side plates made of high-quality materials. Its compact size and ergonomic design make it comfortable to handle, even during long fishing sessions. Equipped with a powerful drag system, this reel allows anglers to easily control the line tension and handle challenging fish with ease. Its gear ratio provides a perfect balance between speed and power, allowing for efficient retrieves and precise bait presentation. Whether you are a seasoned angler or a beginner, the Abu Garcia Ambassadeur C3 is a reliable option that will enhance your freshwater fishing experience.

Shimano Calcutta Conquest

The Shimano Calcutta Conquest is a top-of-the-line trolling reel that offers exceptional performance and durability. Designed for freshwater fishing, this reel is highly regarded by anglers for its precision and smooth operation. The Calcutta Conquest features a high-quality construction, with a solid aluminum frame and side plates that provide excellent rigidity and strength. Its advanced drag system allows for precise adjustments, giving anglers full control over the line tension during intense battles with large fish. The reel’s gear ratio ensures a smooth and efficient retrieve, allowing for precise lure presentation and effective bait manipulation. With its ergonomic design and comfortable grip, the Shimano Calcutta Conquest is a pleasure to use for long hours on the water. Whether you are targeting trophy-sized bass or elusive muskies, this reel will deliver the performance and reliability you need.

Penn Fathom II

The Penn Fathom II is a highly versatile trolling reel that excels in freshwater fishing applications. Known for its robust construction and exceptional performance, this reel has gained a strong reputation among anglers of all skill levels. The Fathom II features a durable full-metal body and side plates, ensuring maximum strength and resistance to corrosion. Its powerful drag system provides smooth and consistent performance, allowing anglers to effortlessly handle aggressive fish. With its high , this reel offers fast retrieves, making it ideal for techniques such as trolling and casting. The Penn Fathom II also boasts a high line capacity, allowing anglers to target a wide range of freshwater species without worrying about running out of line. Whether you are chasing trophy-sized pike or battling feisty salmon, the Penn Fathom II is a reliable and versatile reel that will enhance your freshwater fishing experience.

Okuma Cold Water

The Okuma Cold Water is a reliable and efficient trolling reel that is specifically designed for freshwater fishing. This reel is renowned for its durability and smooth operation, making it a popular choice among anglers who enjoy targeting species such as trout, salmon, and walleye. The Cold Water features a robust construction, with a corrosion-resistant frame and side plates that can withstand the rigors of freshwater fishing. Its precision allows for precise adjustments, ensuring a consistent and reliable performance when battling powerful fish. The reel’s gear ratio provides a perfect balance between speed and power, allowing for efficient retrieves and precise bait presentation. With its comfortable grip and ergonomic design, the Okuma Cold Water offers a comfortable fishing experience even during long days on the water. Whether you are a seasoned angler or a beginner, this reel will exceed your expectations and help you land more fish.

Lew’s Tournament Pro G Speed Spool

The Lew’s Tournament Pro G Speed Spool is a high-performance trolling reel that is favored by freshwater anglers for its exceptional features and reliability. This reel combines cutting-edge technology with a sleek design, making it a standout option in the market. The Tournament Pro G Speed Spool features a lightweight and durable construction, allowing for effortless casting and precise bait presentation. Its advanced drag system delivers smooth and consistent performance, enabling anglers to tackle even the most aggressive freshwater species with ease. The reel’s high gear ratio ensures fast and efficient retrieves, giving anglers an advantage when covering large areas of water. With its ergonomic design and comfortable grip, the Lew’s Tournament Pro G Speed Spool provides a fatigue-free fishing experience. Whether you are a professional angler or a weekend warrior, this reel is a reliable choice that will enhance your freshwater fishing adventures.


Maintenance Tips for Trolling Reels

When it comes to maintaining your trolling reels, a little bit of care can go a long way in ensuring their longevity and optimal performance. Here are some essential to keep your reels in top shape:

Cleaning and Lubrication

Regular cleaning and lubrication are crucial for the smooth operation of your trolling reels. Here’s how you can do it:

  1. Start by rinsing your reel with freshwater after each use. This helps remove any salt, sand, or dirt that may have accumulated during your fishing trip.
  2. Use a soft cloth or brush to gently clean the exterior of the reel. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive materials that can damage the finish.
  3. Disassemble the reel according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Clean each part individually with a mild soap and water solution. Pay special attention to the gears, spool, and drag system.
  4. Once clean, dry each part thoroughly before reassembling the reel. This prevents rust and corrosion from developing.
  5. Apply a high-quality reel lubricant to the gears, bearings, and moving parts. This helps reduce friction and ensures smooth operation. Be sure to use a lubricant specifically designed for fishing reels.
  6. Finally, perform a few test casts to ensure the reel is working smoothly. If you notice any grinding or uneven operation, it may be a sign that further maintenance is required.

Proper Storage

Proper storage is essential to protect your trolling reels from damage and extend their lifespan. Follow these tips for storing your reels:

  1. After each fishing trip, rinse your reel with freshwater to remove any salt or debris.
  2. Thoroughly dry the reel before storing it. Moisture can lead to rust and corrosion, which can greatly affect performance.
  3. Store your reels in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Excessive heat can damage the reel’s internal components and weaken the line.
  4. Consider using reel covers or cases to provide additional protection. These can help prevent scratches and dings during transportation or storage.
  5. Avoid storing your reels in areas prone to high humidity or extreme temperature fluctuations, such as basements or attics.

Regular Inspections

Regular inspections are essential to identify any potential issues with your trolling reels before they become major problems. Here’s what you should inspect:

  1. Check the reel’s exterior for any signs of damage, such as cracks or dents. Pay attention to the handle, drag knob, and spool.
  2. Inspect the line guide and roller for any signs of wear or damage. Replace them if necessary to prevent line breakage.
  3. Examine the drag system for smooth operation. If it feels rough or inconsistent, it may need to be cleaned and lubricated.
  4. Check the gears for any signs of wear or misalignment. Replace any worn or damaged gears to maintain optimal performance.

Replacing Worn Parts

Over time, certain parts of your trolling reel may wear out and need to be replaced. Here are some common parts that may require replacement:

  1. Drag washers: These are located inside the and can wear out with heavy use. Replace them if you notice a decrease in drag performance.
  2. Bearings: Bearings can become corroded or worn out over time. If your reel feels rough or makes grinding noises, it may be time to replace the bearings.
  3. Line guide and roller: These components can wear down due to friction with the fishing line. Replace them if they show signs of excessive wear or damage.
  4. Handle and knobs: If the handle or knobs become loose or show signs of wear, it’s a good idea to replace them to maintain a comfortable grip.

Avoiding Saltwater Corrosion

Saltwater can be particularly harsh on trolling reels due to its corrosive properties. Here are some tips to avoid saltwater corrosion:

  1. Rinse your reel with freshwater immediately after each trip. Pay special attention to the drag system, line guide, and roller.

  2. Use a reel cleaner specifically designed for saltwater use. These cleaners help remove salt and other corrosive substances that can damage your reel.
  3. Apply a corrosion-resistant reel lubricant to all the moving parts. This provides an extra layer of protection against saltwater corrosion.
  4. Consider using a reel cover or case when fishing in saltwater environments. This can help prevent direct exposure to saltwater and reduce the risk of corrosion.

By following these , you can ensure that your trolling reels stay in excellent condition, providing you with smooth and reliable performance for years to come. Remember, a well-maintained reel is essential for a successful fishing experience.


Techniques for Trolling with Reels

Downrigging

Downrigging is a popular technique used by anglers when trolling with reels. It involves the use of a downrigger, which is a device that helps to control the depth at which your lure or bait is presented in the water. By attaching a weight to a cable and lowering it to a desired depth, you can effectively target fish at specific depths in the water column.

Some key points about downrigging include:

  • Downriggers come in various sizes and types, including manual and electric models. Electric downriggers are easier to use and allow for precise depth control.
  • When downrigging, it’s important to adjust the depth based on the target species and their feeding habits. Experimenting with different depths can help you find the sweet spot where the fish are biting.
  • Use a release clip to attach your fishing line to the downrigger cable. This allows the line to be released when a fish strikes, preventing it from feeling the weight of the downrigger and increasing the chances of a successful hookup.
  • Downrigging is particularly effective for targeting species like salmon, trout, and walleye, which tend to inhabit deeper waters.

Planer Boards

Planer boards are another useful tool when trolling with reels, especially in situations where you want to cover a larger area of water or present multiple lines simultaneously. These boards are attached to your fishing line and deploy to the sides of your boat, spreading out your lines and helping to avoid tangles.

Here are some key points about using planer boards:

  • Planer boards come in different sizes, with larger boards being more suitable for trolling in rougher conditions or when using heavier tackle.
  • Attach your fishing line to the planer board using release clips or line releases. This allows the board to slide along the line when a fish strikes, reducing resistance and increasing the chances of a solid hookup.
  • When using planer boards, it’s important to pay attention to the distance between the board and your lure or bait. Adjusting this distance can help you target fish at different depths and increase your chances of success.
  • Planer boards are particularly effective for targeting species like walleye, pike, and muskie, which often roam near the surface or in shallow waters.

Diving Plugs

Diving plugs, also known as crankbaits, are a type of lure that can be used when trolling with reels. These lures are designed to imitate the swimming action of baitfish, making them irresistible to predatory fish.

Consider these points when using diving plugs:

  • Diving plugs come in different sizes and diving depths. Choosing the right plug depends on the target species and the depth at which they are feeding. Pay attention to the diving depth range specified by the manufacturer.
  • Vary your trolling speed to control the diving depth of the plug. Slower speeds will cause the plug to dive deeper, while faster speeds will keep it closer to the surface.
  • Experiment with different colors and patterns to see what the fish are responding to. Bright and vibrant colors can be effective in murky water, while more natural colors work well in clear water.
  • Diving plugs are versatile and can be used to target a wide range of fish species, including bass, walleye, and pike.

Trolling Spoons

Trolling spoons are another popular choice for anglers who want to troll with reels. These metal lures have a curved shape that mimics the movement of a wounded baitfish, attracting predatory fish.

Consider these points when using trolling spoons:

  • Trolling spoons come in various sizes and colors. The size of the spoon should match the size of the baitfish in the area you are targeting.
  • Vary your trolling speed to control the action of the spoon. Slower speeds will produce a wider wobbling action, while faster speeds will create a tighter and faster action.
  • Experiment with different spoon colors to find what works best in the specific conditions you are fishing. Silver and gold are popular choices, but don’t be afraid to try brighter colors or patterns.
  • Trolling spoons are effective for targeting a variety of species, including salmon, trout, and muskie.

Trolling Flies

Trolling with flies can be a productive technique, especially when targeting species like trout, salmon, and steelhead. These flies are designed to imitate aquatic insects or small baitfish and are typically fished using a sinking or sinking-tip line.

Consider these points when trolling with flies:

  • Choose flies that closely resemble the insects or baitfish present in the water you are fishing. Matching the hatch is crucial for success.
  • Use sinking or sinking-tip lines to get your flies to the desired depth. Adjust the length of the leader to control the presentation.
  • Vary your trolling speed to imitate the movement of the flies. Slower speeds can mimic a struggling insect, while faster speeds can mimic a fleeing baitfish.
  • Trolling with flies requires patience and attention to detail. Keep an eye out for rises or other signs of fish activity, as this can indicate where to focus your efforts.

By employing these techniques for trolling with reels, you can increase your chances of success on the water. Whether you’re downrigging, using planer boards, or trolling with specific lures like diving plugs, spoons, or flies, each technique has its own advantages and can be tailored to suit different fishing conditions and target species.


Trolling Reels vs. Casting Reels

Line Capacity and Control

When it comes to line capacity and control, trolling reels and casting reels have distinct differences. Trolling reels are specifically designed to hold larger amounts of fishing line, allowing anglers to target bigger fish that may require longer line runs. With their larger spools and deeper line capacity, trolling reels provide the necessary room for heavier lines and increased line length.

On the other hand, casting reels excel in precision and accuracy. They are designed for casting lures and baits with pinpoint accuracy, making them ideal for targeting specific areas or structures. While casting reels may not have the same line capacity as trolling reels, they make up for it with their ability to control the line during the casting process. The spool design and braking systems on casting reels allow for better control over the line, resulting in more accurate casts.

Gear Ratio and Retrieval Speed

The gear ratio of a reel determines the speed at which the line is retrieved. Trolling reels typically have lower gear ratios compared to casting reels. This is because trolling involves slowly moving the bait or lure through the water, requiring a slower retrieval speed. The lower of trolling reels allows for a more controlled and steady retrieve, making it easier to maintain a consistent trolling speed.

On the other hand, casting reels often have higher gear ratios, allowing for faster retrieval speeds. This is advantageous when targeting fast-moving fish or when needing to quickly retrieve a lure to make multiple casts in a short amount of time. The higher of casting reels provides a quicker line retrieval, resulting in increased efficiency and versatility.

Drag System and Fighting Power

The drag system of a reel plays a crucial role in battling and landing fish. Trolling reels are designed to handle the demands of fighting larger fish, with robust drag systems that offer substantial stopping power. The drag on trolling reels can be adjusted to exert varying amounts of pressure, allowing anglers to control the fight and prevent the line from breaking under intense pressure.

Casting reels, on the other hand, are typically not designed to handle the same level of fighting power as trolling reels. While they still have drag systems, they are generally not as powerful as those found on trolling reels. Casting reels are more suited for finesse fishing and targeting smaller to medium-sized fish that may not put as much strain on the drag system.

Versatility and Target Species

Both trolling reels and casting reels have their own areas of specialization when it comes to target species. Trolling reels are commonly used in for species like tuna, marlin, and salmon, which require long line runs and the ability to handle heavy loads. They are also effective for freshwater fishing when targeting large species like muskie or pike.

Casting reels, on the other hand, are highly versatile and can be used for a wide range of freshwater fishing applications. They are particularly popular for bass fishing, where precision casting and lure presentation are crucial. Casting reels are also commonly used for targeting species like walleye, trout, and panfish.

Line Management and Tangle Prevention

Trolling reels and casting reels differ in their approach to line management and tangle prevention. Trolling reels often feature specialized line guides and levelwind systems that distribute the line evenly across the spool, minimizing the chances of tangles and line twists. These features are especially important when trolling with multiple lines or using downriggers.

Casting reels, on the other hand, require more manual line management. Anglers must be mindful of their casting technique to prevent backlash and tangles, especially when using baitcasting reels. Proper thumb control and spool tension adjustment are essential for smooth and tangle-free casts. However, modern casting reels often come with advanced braking systems that help reduce the risk of backlash and tangles.

In conclusion, choosing between trolling reels and casting reels ultimately depends on the specific fishing techniques and target species. Trolling reels excel in , controlled retrieval, fighting power, and are ideal for larger fish in both saltwater and freshwater environments. On the other hand, casting reels offer precision casting, versatility, and are commonly used for freshwater fishing, particularly for bass and other smaller to medium-sized species. Understanding the differences and strengths of each type of reel will help you make an informed decision based on your fishing needs and preferences.

Leave a Comment